Do V-nosed Trailers Tow Better?
It seems there’s a bit of a myth being spread about by trailer salesman. The claim is that v-nose trailers are more aerodynamic and do not have a tendency to sway as much as flat-fronted trailers. Travel trailers like the one pictured below seem to be the new industry trend, as manufacturers use every trick at their disposal to create more space with less length.
Aerodynamic shape?
When I
was a first-year engineering student at Lawrence Tech University in Michigan,
our instructor put several shapes up on the board and asked which was the most
aerodynamic. Almost every student pointed to the V shape.
We were
wrong. Our instructor then put up a side view of a Navy jet aircraft.
Naturally, any aircraft manufacturer will choose the most aerodynamic shape
possible. Our jet aircraft all have a teardrop shape, with the wide end
pointing forward. That’s because it is the turbulent air that runs alongside
the body of an aircraft, or trailer, that causes the most drag and turbulence.
A V
shape does not deter turbulence. In fact, it makes it worse. Now you have wind
pushing against two sides and not away from the trailer.
What is a good trailer design?
If we
could design a trailer based on the teardrop shape, we would. However, it just
isn’t a good use of interior space. Some manufacturers, like Airstream,
Earthbound, Galileo, and a few others utilize a rounded front end, like the
front end of the teardrop. This is the most aerodynamic design available that
is also feasible for good interior space utilization.
Even
with the more aerodynamic shape, all trailers will experience trailer sway. There’s no way to avoid the side-winds and passing trucks
that will push against the side of the trailer. Uneven roads and sudden evasive
steering will also cause a trailer to sway.
Benefits of V-nose trailers
That
being said, I can’t simply discard the v-nose as a passing fad or bad idea. The
space provided by these designs may very well make up for the decreased tow
ability. The front kitchen design provides acres (okay, maybe not acres) of
extra counter space. In a day when trailers are getting smaller, any extra
square foot is worth any downside.
Comments
Post a Comment